One night in September, Sonia Romero and her
husband Agustin — now among 20 tenants facing eviction from run-down
one-bedroom apartments on North Raymond Avenue in Altadena — trapped a
dozen rodents.
But that wasn’t the last time the family had to
endure that type of horror. Two weeks ago, Sonia Romero was shocked and
appalled to find mice crawling on her sons, Eduardo, 3, and little
1-year-old David, as they slept.
Although such problems would
force most tenants to seek another place to live, the Romeros and
others living in the small one-bedroom cottages located just south of
Woodbury Road in Altadena, along the city line with Pasadena, can’t
afford a bigger, better apartment.
“We don’t have any money to
leave and we don’t have anyplace to go,” Sonia said. “My husband
doesn’t have a job. It’s been really hard for him to find work.”
But
they may be forced onto the streets anyway. Property owner Ahmad Nowaid
has already served 20 tenants — many of them families — with eviction
notices, including the Romeros, who have all complained about
unsanitary conditions at the complex.
And, unfortunately, there may be nothing anyone can do about it.
According
to California Civil Code 1946.1, “The landlord can serve the tenant
notice to vacate within 30 days. The landlord does not have to provide
any reason for the eviction, unless a rent control ordinance requires
just cause. If the tenant does not leave within 30 days of the notice,
the landlord can file a suit for the eviction.”
However, those
tenants are claiming that Nowaid broke the law when he refused to fix
troublesome plumbing that continuously backs up into kitchen sinks and
bathtubs, leaving a rancid odor. The tenants claim he has also failed
to deal with pervasive insect and rodent infestation, similar to the
problems in Romero’s apartment.
To that end, they have all
refused to pay rent — which ranges between $850 to $950 per unit per
month — and have placed the money into an escrow account.
Tenants
can legally withhold rent if the landlord has not complied with the
warranty of habitability, according to California Civil Code 1941.
But
Nowaid doesn’t seem to care. “By law, we have to give them 30 days
notice,” he told the Weekly. “We gave them 60 days notice. We are not
kicking everyone out, just people in some units that we are going to
rehab. We are not going to let those tenants move back in, because they
have refused to pay their rent. The bottom line is they are out there
trying not to pay their rent. I used pesticides on the units. There are
no problems.”
Tenants say Nowaid plans to place dividing walls in
their apartments, turning each apartment into two small studios, then
keep the rent the same in order to make even more money off the
property that he purchased in July.
Attorney Philip Koebel has
filed a complaint in Superior Court on behalf of 10 of the families
involved, alleging “a breach of implied warranty of habitability,
breach of the rental agreement/lease and the failure to provide
habitable premises.”
Koebel is asking for at least the equivalent
of a couple of months rent to help families relocate. He would settle
for Nowaid agreeing to allow the families to stay until the end of the
school year, since many of them have children in local schools.
“A
lot of people have been here just for a year,” Koebel said. “We’re not
talking about lifelong residents, but they have all expressed the same
concerns — that before it was sold they were getting some response from
management. After the sale, they were told that the repairs weren’t
going to be done because the whole place is going to be repaired after
everyone moved out; not technically illegal, but it heads towards
[breaching] the warranty of habitability.”
The warranty of
habitability guarantees tenants a safe and healthy living environment,
free of infestation and faulty wiring, and with adequate containers for
refuse.
“The bugs are all over the house,” said 20-year-old
Cruz Bravo. “When we got here, there were a few roaches and spiders,
but when they started doing construction, they came out more. Our sink
gets clogged up and smells really, really badly. The spiders and
roaches climb through a vent hole. I am scared for my 4-year-old
brother.”
Like Romero, Bravo is living in an apartment way too
small for four people. The 20-year-old caregiver, who lives with her
mother and two siblings, said that when her mother complained about the
bugs, the landlord did nothing, forcing her to cover the vent with
tape. They then placed an entertainment center over it.
“I am
shocked somebody would do this,” said Bravo. “He has no heart. How
could he just come in and tell 20 people to leave? I am sure if he was
in our situation he would look at it in a different way, but it’s very
heartless of him to just come and say I don’t care what you have or
what you don’t have, just go.”
Earlier this year, Nowaid
fumigated the units. He admitted that he did it himself and gave the
tenants less than 12 hours notice on a Friday night that he would be
spraying for bugs.
Reportedly, tenants were told they had to be
out by 9 a.m. the following Saturday because their units would not get
bombed if they remained. Several tenants had nowhere to go and their
units were not fumigated. According to Bravo, the roaches hid in those
apartments and returned a month later with a vengeance.
“If we
have to get up and go, we’ll put everything in storage and hopefully we
can stay with my uncle in LA,” Bravo said. “I hope that doesn’t happen
because LA is pretty far. My mom goes to work at 7 and my sister goes
to school at 7. They would have to leave every day around 5 a.m. so
they don’t catch any traffic. It will be hard for my mother because I
get off at 7 a.m. and there would be no way I could help her. We’re
here because this is what we can afford.”
FAIR USE NOTICE. This document may contain copyrighted
material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the
copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our
website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in
California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such
copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright
Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your
own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright
owner.